The Problem with Problem Statements : El problema con la declaración del problema

Un enfoque brillante y pragmático para la resolución de problemas. Dime algo si queréis que traduzca a castellano. He dejado esto en el idioma original, ya que hay algunas joyas que son difíciles de traducir, pero puedo traducir si queréis que lo haga. (A. Ward)

Things I wish I had said:

The secret to success is to get your arms around a problem and knock it off ~ Anon

Worse than not saying it myself is the fact that I don’t entirely know who did say it, but we shouldn’t dwell on my failings.

On a more positive note, quotes that I can attribute include:

A problem well stated is a problem half solved ~ Charles F. Kettering

(If I had sixty minutes to save the world) I would spend fifty-five minutes defining the problem and only five minutes finding the solution ~ Albert  Einstein

Poorly structured logic

I shouldn’t base a logical argument on a bunch of quotes, but take the mental leap with me, it is clear that being able to define a problem well is a skill worth having in life.

Which leads to the question…

How do you define a problem?

I have had a good look on Google, but I am afraid it all becomes a bit woolly and vague, let me give you a summary of the top 8 tips:

1. Chunk the problem down:

Some problems are just a little too difficult.  If you can split them up you stand more chance.  Putting a man on the moon is a big ask, a sensible problem to start with might be: how do you put a dog into space?

2. Chunk the problem up:

Some problems aren’t really the problem; you should find the bigger problem you need to solve.  Is the problem that you need to go to the gym?  Or is it really that you want to live a long and healthy life?

In which case maybe you should chunk the problem back down and stop smoking.

I do hope this is becoming clear

3. Get specific:

Get the facts and write them down.  Problems are rarely “always”, “everywhere” and “everybody”.

If in doubt about the facts go and look at the problem (there is no better way)

4. Be explicit:

Expose the assumptions, ask what they are and the write them down.  Make them as explicit as possible and then you can challenge them.

Trite but true: if you “assume” you make an “ass” out of “u” and “me”.  (My 9-year-old daughter told me that).

5. Follow the formula:

A problem statement should have an object and a defect; it should not contain a solution, otherwise it wouldn’t be a problem would it? (see below)

6. State the pain:

If the problem is “we need a bandage” then technically that is a solution looking for a problem.  Solutions looking for problems are very expensive things (usually involving multi million pound IT investments)

Write down where it hurts, not that you need a bandage.  P.S. You can do this by following the formula. (see above)

7. Tell me what the problem isn’t:

Write down all the things that aren’t the problem, “everybody is late” and “everybody is late except Tony and Sue” are two very different propositions to deal with.

It is best to do this with things that are closely related to what the problem is, or you could go on for a very long time.

8. Rephrase the problem:

How you state a problem determines how they interpret it:

  • “Ways to increase productivity” sounds like job cutting
  • “Ways to make our work easier” sounds like knocking off early.

I guess you will get more traction with the latter

The problem with writing problem statements

All of this is sound advice, but none of it is very definitive.  There aren’t any golden rules.

How about this as a sense check?  If you honestly think that if you can:

Get your arms around [insert your problem statement here] and knock it off

Then you might just be successful in life.  Unfortunately that is kind of where we started.


Acerca de ayurvedicteas

Tea drinker and the man in Spain for The Wise Herb Company


Introduce tus datos o haz clic en un icono para iniciar sesión:

Logo de

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Imagen de Twitter

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Twitter. Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Foto de Facebook

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Facebook. Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Google+ photo

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Google+. Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Conectando a %s

A %d blogueros les gusta esto: